What Law Governed Restitution?
Restitution—the act of restoring what was lost, damaged, or stolen—was a central feature of ancient Israel’s legal system. Rather than focusing mainly on imprisonment or physical punishment, biblical law emphasized responsibility, accountability, and repair. The goal was to make the victim whole again and to cultivate justice within the community.
The laws governing restitution are primarily found in Exodus 22:1–15, immediately following the civil and moral laws given at Mount Sinai.
1. Restitution for Theft (Exodus 22:1–4)
Theft was considered not only a crime but a violation of the neighbor’s security and livelihood. Restitution laws required repayment beyond the stolen amount to deter wrongdoing.
a. Stealing Livestock
Livestock were valuable property, so the penalty was significant.
-
If a man stole an ox, he must repay five oxen.
-
If he stole a sheep, he must restore four sheep.
This multiple repayment (fourfold or fivefold) reflected the seriousness of theft and the impact on the victim’s livelihood.
b. If the Stolen Animal Was Found Alive
If the thief was caught with the animal still in his possession—alive and unharmed—he had to repay double the value.
This distinction encouraged thieves to surrender early rather than destroy or sell the stolen property.
c. When the Thief Could Not Pay
If the thief lacked resources, he could be sold into servitude to make restitution.
This was not slavery as oppression, but a temporary arrangement to repay the debt.
2. Restitution for Property Damage (Exodus 22:5–6)
a. Damage Caused by Livestock
If someone’s livestock wandered into another’s field and grazed there, restitution required repayment from the best of the offender’s crops—grain, vineyard produce, or fields.
This ensured fairness: the victim did not receive inferior compensation.
b. Fires That Spread Accidentally
If a person started a fire—intentionally or unintentionally—and it spread to another’s field, he was required to make full restitution.
This law emphasized personal responsibility even for unintentional harm.
3. Restitution for Lost Property Entrusted to Another (Exodus 22:7–13)
God also included detailed laws for property given for safekeeping.
a. If the Guardian Misused the Item
If money or goods were entrusted to someone and later stolen, the guardian must bring the case before judges.
-
If he was found guilty of negligence or misuse, he must repay double the amount.
b. If No Misuse Was Found
If the thief was caught, he alone repaid double, and the guardian was cleared.
c. When Property Was Injured or Died
If an entrusted item (such as an animal) was hurt or died without any witnesses, the keeper must take an oath of innocence.
If accepted, he bore no responsibility for restitution.
This prevented false accusations and protected both parties.
4. Restitution for Borrowed Property (Exodus 22:14–15)
a. Borrowed Items Damaged
If a person borrowed something and it was damaged or died while in his care, he must make full restitution.
Borrowing implied responsibility.
b. Exceptions
If the owner was present when the damage occurred, or if the item came as part of hired labor, no restitution was required.
This distinguished between negligence and normal risk.
The Principles Behind Restitution Law
1. Justice Focused on Restoration
The goal was to restore the victim, not simply punish the offender.
2. Responsibility and Accountability
Every person was responsible for the consequences of his actions—whether intentional or accidental.
3. Respect for Property
Property was tied to survival. Protecting it preserved community stability.
4. Fairness and Proportionality
Penalties matched the crime—more severe for intentional theft, less severe for accidental loss.
Conclusion
The law governing restitution in Scripture reflects a society built on justice, fairness, and compassion. Instead of harsh punishments, the emphasis was on making the wrong right. Through repayment, responsibility, and restoration, these laws cultivated trust and protected community life. The principles behind them remain relevant today as foundations for ethical living, personal accountability, and restorative justice.