How Did Joseph Deal With His Brothers During Their First Visit?

An in-depth study of Genesis 42 and Joseph’s wisdom, restraint, and spiritual discernment

The first meeting between Joseph and his brothers in Egypt is one of the most emotionally charged scenes in the book of Genesis. More than twenty years had passed since they sold him into slavery. Now, because of the famine Joseph had predicted, these same brothers unknowingly stood before him—bowing down—asking for food.

Joseph’s response was neither impulsive revenge nor immediate reconciliation. Instead, he acted with wisdom, testing them to see whether their hearts had changed and whether they were ready for restoration.

This article explores in detail how Joseph dealt with his brothers on their first visit to Egypt and why he acted the way he did.

1. Joseph Recognized His Brothers, but They Did Not Recognize Him

When the brothers arrived, Genesis 42:7–8 states:

Joseph recognized them immediately.
They did not recognize him.

Reasons they did not identify him:

He was dressed in Egyptian royal attire.
He spoke through an interpreter (Genesis 42:23).
He was older and appeared as an Egyptian noble.
Joseph’s rise to power was unimaginable to them.

Joseph’s recognition stirred deep emotion, but he concealed it to observe their character.

2. Joseph Remembered His Dreams and Understood God’s Hand

Genesis 42:9 says, “Joseph remembered the dreams” he had as a youth—dreams that depicted his brothers bowing before him (Genesis 37:7–9).

This moment confirmed that:

God’s plan was unfolding exactly as foretold.
Joseph’s suffering had purpose.
This meeting was divinely orchestrated.
It was not time for revenge, but for discernment and testing.

Joseph understood he was standing in a prophetic moment.

3. Joseph Treated Them Harshly—Not Out of Hatred, but to Test Them

Joseph intentionally spoke harshly (Genesis 42:7). This was not cruelty; it was a strategy.

Why Joseph acted sternly:

To conceal his identity
To prevent premature emotional reaction
To test their hearts and motives
To see whether they regretted their past actions
To check whether they still mistreated Benjamin as they had mistreated him

The harsh tone created pressure that revealed character.

4. Joseph Accused Them of Being Spies

Joseph said:

“You are spies! You have come to see the nakedness of the land!”
—Genesis 42:9–14

Why this accusation?

It forced them to speak openly about their family.
It revealed information Joseph needed (their father was alive, Benjamin existed).
It tested whether they would stick together instead of betraying one another again.
It provided a legitimate pretext for detaining them.

This interrogation exposed their hearts and their loyalty.

5. Joseph Tested Their Honesty by Demanding Benjamin

When the brothers insisted they were honest men, Joseph said:

“Send one of you to get your youngest brother.”
—Genesis 42:16

Why Benjamin was crucial:

Benjamin was Joseph’s only full brother.
Joseph wanted to see whether they had mistreated him too.
Their willingness to protect Benjamin would reveal whether they had truly changed.

Benjamin became the key to Joseph’s test.

6. Joseph Imprisoned His Brothers for Three Days

Joseph placed all the brothers in custody for three days (Genesis 42:17).

Purposes of the imprisonment:

To mirror the suffering they had caused him.
To produce reflection and repentance.
To increase the psychological pressure.
To provide time for Joseph to plan his next steps without revealing his identity.

Those three days reset the tone of the entire encounter.

7. Joseph Adjusted His Plan—Showing Mercy

On the third day, Joseph softened the plan:

“Do this and live, for I fear God.”
—Genesis 42:18

He changed the plan from sending nine and keeping one, to sending all but one.

His mercy included:

Releasing nine brothers
Keeping only Simeon (likely the most aggressive in past actions)
Providing grain for their entire household
Secretly returning their money

Joseph balanced justice with compassion.

8. Joseph Listened as His Brothers Acknowledged Their Guilt

Before leaving, the brothers said to one another:

“Surely we are being punished because of our brother…”
—Genesis 42:21

They confessed:

their guilt
their cruelty
their lack of mercy
their responsibility for Joseph’s suffering

Joseph understood this as a sign of spiritual awakening.

Joseph’s reaction?

He turned away and wept (Genesis 42:24).

This was the first of several moments where Joseph’s hidden compassion overflowed.

9. Joseph Bound Simeon and Sent the Others Home With Grain and Returned Payment

Joseph detained Simeon publicly, likely because:

Simeon was the second oldest
Simeon was known for violence (Genesis 34)
He may have been a ringleader in Joseph’s betrayal

He then:

Filled their sacks with grain
Secretly returned their silver
Provided supplies for their journey (Genesis 42:25)

Why return the money?

To test their honesty
To intensify their fear of wrongdoing
To show subtle mercy
To increase the likelihood of their return

Joseph’s strategy was both psychological and spiritual.

10. Joseph Forced the Brothers Into a Position Where They Must Return

By requiring Benjamin and leaving Simeon behind, Joseph ensured:

they would have to come back
Jacob would face the truth of scarcity
the family would be moved toward restoration
the brothers would make choices revealing whether they had changed

This was the beginning of a process, not the conclusion.

Conclusion: Joseph’s Actions Were Driven by Wisdom, Not Revenge

During their first visit, Joseph:

Recognized his brothers
Hid his identity
Spoke harshly to test their hearts
Accused them to prompt confession
Demanded Benjamin as proof of honesty
Imprisoned them briefly
Showed mercy by releasing nine of them
Safeguarded Simeon
Returned their money
Initiated a plan for deeper reconciliation

Joseph’s approach balanced justice, wisdom, emotion, and discernment. He did not rush into forgiveness without evidence of repentance, nor did he seek revenge for past wrongs.

His actions initiated a spiritual transformation in his brothers that would culminate in full reconciliation in their later visits.

Urdu Bible اردو بائبل

Or check our Popular Categories...