What Prevented the Brothers from Killing Joseph Immediately?
When Joseph’s brothers plotted against him, their first instinct was violent: “Let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits.” Their jealousy, anger, and resentment had reached a boiling point. Yet, despite their murderous intentions, Joseph was not killed. Several important factors worked together—both human and divine—to prevent immediate bloodshed. These reasons reveal the complexity of the family dynamics and the unseen protection of God’s hand over Joseph’s life.
1. Reuben’s Intervention Slowed the Plot
The primary and most direct reason Joseph was not killed immediately was Reuben, the eldest brother.
-
As the firstborn, Reuben held a position of responsibility.
-
Though flawed in other areas of life, he demonstrated a moment of moral clarity when he heard the brothers’ plan.
Reuben strongly opposed shedding Joseph’s blood:
“Let us not take his life… shed no blood; cast him into this pit in the wilderness, but lay no hand upon him.”
Reuben’s goal was not to leave Joseph there permanently. Scripture notes that he intended to rescue Joseph later and return him secretly to their father.
His intervention slowed the momentum of violence and prevented an immediate murder.
2. The Brothers Chose a Less Direct Method of Harm
After Reuben spoke, the brothers shifted their approach.
-
Instead of killing Joseph directly, they stripped him of his tunic and threw him into an empty cistern.
-
This action was fueled by hatred but lacked the finality of murder.
This change in plans reflects how group emotions can be interrupted by a stronger voice—even temporarily.
Their anger was still burning, but the decisive step of killing him with their own hands suddenly felt harder to justify after Reuben spoke.
3. Judah’s Later Proposal Reinforced the Delay
While Reuben initially stopped them from killing Joseph at once, Judah later influenced them further.
When the brothers saw the approaching Ishmaelite caravan, Judah suggested:
“What profit is there if we kill our brother… let us sell him instead.”
Judah’s suggestion appealed to their emotions and self-interest.
-
It avoided guilt for spilling blood.
-
It offered financial gain.
-
It allowed them to rid themselves of Joseph without committing outright murder.
Judah’s reasoning created yet another opportunity for delay, preventing an immediate or impulsive killing.
4. The Presence of the Cistern Created an Interim Step
The empty cistern played a subtle but significant role.
-
Because the pit was available, the brothers used it as a holding place for Joseph.
-
This physical separation offered enough time for their anger to cool slightly and for other ideas to emerge.
Without the cistern, the moment may have escalated more quickly. But the pit acted as a pause in the sequence of violence.
5. Divine Providence Overruled Human Malice
Beyond human choices, the most profound reason Joseph was not killed immediately was God’s sovereign protection.
-
Joseph’s dreams foretold a future of leadership and preservation.
-
God’s plan required Joseph to live.
-
Every “interruption”—Reuben’s words, Judah’s suggestion, the arrival of the caravan—was part of divine orchestration.
Even though Joseph’s brothers acted from jealousy and hatred, they could not escape God’s timing or purpose.
What they meant for evil, God was already shaping for good.
6. The Arrival of the Ishmaelite Traders Came at the Perfect Time
The sudden appearance of a caravan of Ishmaelites/Midianites was not a coincidence.
-
Their arrival presented an alternative to murder.
-
It created a moment where greed and opportunity overshadowed violence.
Had the traders not appeared, the brothers might have continued with their original plan.
But this providential timing stopped their murderous intent from becoming immediate action.
Conclusion: A Murder Delayed, a Life Preserved
Joseph’s brothers did not kill him immediately because of a combination of human intervention and divine orchestration:
-
Reuben’s leadership delayed the act.
-
Judah offered a non-lethal alternative.
-
The cistern provided a holding place.
-
The traders arrived at a critical moment.
-
God protected Joseph through each step.
While the brothers were driven by hatred, God controlled the outcome. The delay that saved Joseph’s life also set in motion God’s plan to elevate him in Egypt and ultimately save his family from famine.
Joseph lived because heaven had a purpose that human jealousy could not destroy.